|
Post by Roc on Nov 4, 2008 12:38:55 GMT -5
His tally was wrong at least twice. Soban voted for Goats on page 30 and I voted for Cern on page 35. I even sent a PM to Cern to inform him of his mistake and he chose to let it stand uncorrected.
Here is the correct tally from Day 1:
7 Votes: /Lynch Goats (rinjo) /Lynch Goats (WildKnight) /Lynch Goats (me) /Lynch Goats (Thuellai) /Lynch Goats (Presto) /Lynch Goats (hero2490) /Lynch Goats (Nigromante) /Lynch Goats (Soban)
2 Votes: /Lynch Thuellai (Mr. Sinister) /Lynch Thuellai (McFly)
2 Votes: /Lynch Cernunnos56 (Revan) /Lynch Cernunnos56 (Roc)
1 Vote: /Lynch rinjo (Toast)
|
|
|
Post by GhostKnight on Nov 4, 2008 13:18:55 GMT -5
His tally was wrong at least twice. Soban voted for Goats on page 30 and I voted for Cern on page 35. I even sent a PM to Cern to inform him of his mistake and he chose to let it stand uncorrected. Here is the correct tally from Day 1: 7 Votes: /Lynch Goats (rinjo) /Lynch Goats (WildKnight) /Lynch Goats (me) /Lynch Goats (Thuellai) /Lynch Goats (Presto) /Lynch Goats (hero2490) /Lynch Goats (Nigromante) /Lynch Goats (Soban) 2 Votes: /Lynch Thuellai (Mr. Sinister) /Lynch Thuellai (McFly) 2 Votes: /Lynch Cernunnos56 (Revan) /Lynch Cernunnos56 (Roc) 1 Vote: /Lynch rinjo (Toast) Don't surprise me, after all he was all about deception.
|
|
|
Post by Revan on Nov 4, 2008 13:18:54 GMT -5
If we can't come to a consensus of who the serial killer is, or who the mafia members are, maybe we should change the focus on identifying people who are definately townies.
|
|
|
Post by Presto on Nov 4, 2008 13:47:14 GMT -5
If we can't come to a consensus of who the serial killer is, or who the mafia members are, maybe we should change the focus on identifying people who are definately townies. True, but how can we be certain whose townies? We are no more likely to be able to figure that out than we are whose mafiaso or SerialKiller/Vigilante. Probably the only person who we're certain is a townie was Thuel.
|
|
|
Post by WildKnight on Nov 4, 2008 14:05:07 GMT -5
Thats not at all certain either. Assuming he was killed by the mafia (which is a fair assumption, but not provable), he still could have been a serial killer or vigilante himself.
|
|
|
Post by Presto on Nov 4, 2008 14:06:17 GMT -5
Throwing this out here.... Assuming Cern was truly mafiaso.... Who was his original target? Nigromante. He even stated in his early posts that he thought it was intelligent for Mafiaso to vote for one of their own to throw suspicion off both of t hem... But the moment Nigromante looked like he WOULD be lynched, Cern immediately tried to change tactics. I dont know, im reading the first day bit by bit... and this just strikes me as a possibility. It could point to Nigromante being Mafia, but no solid leads.... but what solid leads do we really have to go with here? Anybody else? *Not making an actual vote until he finishes reading the thread* Thats not at all certain either. Assuming he was killed by the mafia (which is a fair assumption, but not provable), he still could have been a serial killer or vigilante himself. True, maybe im just hoping it was a mob hit... because otherwise, if Thuel was Mafiaso, then I was likely aiding him in trying to lynch Cern who would have been a townie. Still though, we have no proof positive either way. And i'm going by my instincts that it was a mob hit.
|
|
|
Post by WildKnight on Nov 4, 2008 14:09:12 GMT -5
Well, obviously I was fine with lynching him the first day, I'm fine with lynching him the second.
|
|
|
Post by Presto on Nov 4, 2008 14:10:44 GMT -5
Im going to wait to see if anyone else stands out to me before I jump the gun... but for now, I got classes, so I cant finish. *Poofs off*
|
|
|
Post by Dullahan on Nov 4, 2008 16:16:40 GMT -5
This would be so much easier if someone just confessed.
|
|
|
Post by Dullahan on Nov 4, 2008 16:33:55 GMT -5
No chuck, that would be the opposite of helpful.
|
|
|
Post by soban on Nov 4, 2008 16:35:15 GMT -5
Can we get a prelim thoughts?
Mine is presto
|
|
|
Post by Dullahan on Nov 4, 2008 16:38:01 GMT -5
Any reason for that? Mine's mcfly, for reasons already stated.
|
|
|
Post by GhostKnight on Nov 4, 2008 18:16:32 GMT -5
Honestly I have no solid leads against anyone of you.
The most likely mafioso (or Serial Killer/Vigilante) was Cern and I get there is no rule against the mafia killing one of their own.
I accept going after the most chaty ones is nonsense yet we have no leads of who is mafia.
BTW, what reasons do you have to lynch McFly?
|
|
|
Post by Roc on Nov 4, 2008 18:47:14 GMT -5
I think Presto makes an interesting point about Cern and Nigromante. Cern's overall actions throughout Day 1 ultimately lead me to suspect him as Mafia, and the tricky strategy of voting for another Mafia would not be unusual for his behavior. Sorry, Nigro, for the bad news. On a different note, I've been looking through the various sites dedicated to this game and found an interesting role, Vigilante with a Persecution Complex. They must kill someone that targets them in the night. www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Worst_Roles_EverLol, sorry again Nigro, cuz according to my records Cern only voted to lynch you, Thullei, himself, and Goats. Since three out of those 4 are dead, and you are the only one left, YOU could be that Vig!! but I doubt it, as it is in the worst roles ever page, lol.
|
|
|
Post by Presto on Nov 4, 2008 18:48:08 GMT -5
I'v been thinking about it all day... and incase I cant get more time to read. I'm just throwing out my vote, incase I let the time pass up on me.
Lynch Nigromante
For reasons stated above... even though its assuming some things I don't know, Its better going on SOME basis of reasoning than just picking at random.
|
|